CFP Rankings
- Five teams showed up on all the ballots. Three usual suspects: Alabama, Clemson, and Oklahoma. The recently dispatched from playoff contention: Wisconsin. And a darkhorse ACC Champion contender: Virginia Tech
- Surprising omissions from the unanimous selections (omitting offender in parentheses): Georgia (Jack) and Ohio State (Joe)
- Seven teams made the cut as one-offs:
- Florida - Josh, his alumni blood runs deep into The Swamp
- App State & Oklahoma State - Joe, I assume he's a Mountaineer or RockClimber or Moccasin or whatever App State's mascot is because no one in their right mind would include them over Ohio State unless they have multiple degrees and a hilltop bungalow in Blowing Rock. His inclusion of the Pokes is looking like a masterstroke as they have looked good on both sides of the ball so far this season.
- Iowa, NC State, & Utah - Adam, I didn't attend any of these schools so my inclusion of them as one-offs is simply an oversight on y'alls parts. The Hawkeyes will ascend to mediocrity in a weak division, the Wolfpack are coming off an emerging season with a stud QB, and the Utes will likely disappoint. 2-out-of-3 ain't bad.
- Michigan State - Chris, they've looked shaky & unreliable. Maybe Chris gets lucky and catches them on the upswing at the end of the season and cashes in 20 pts.
CFP Playoff
- The playoff field is full of lots of overlap of Crimson Tide, Tigers, and Bulldogs, so there won't really be any separation here unless TCU (Sam) or Notre Dame (Adam) sneak in somehow. Both are looking unlikely for different reasons.
National Champ
- Its a two-bandwagon race between Alabama (Jack, Larry, Josh, Joe, & Sam) and Georgia (Adam & Chris). That's it. If they meet for the rematch, we'll have 50 pts swinging back & forth all night.
Power 5
- ACC: Clemson (all of you) vs Virginia Tech (me). Of course, it might just be Syracuse or BC vs VA Tech....hahahahahaha. Probably not, we'll see on Dec 1.
- Big Ten: Ohio State (Jack & Sam) vs Wisconsin (Larry, Josh, Joe, Adam, & Chris). The Big Ten is a mess after this weekend. It could be Iowa vs Penn State come December, who knows.
- Big 12: Our first three-horse race with Oklahoma (Jack, Larry, Josh & Joe) vs TCU (Sam & Adam) vs West Virginia (Chris). Oklahoma always looks like the Greatest Show on Turf right up until they see any semblance of a defense which is hard to come by in the Big 12 (unless OK State is fo real). TCU and WVU certainly won't make it easy. I assume all those games will be 56-49 track meets.
- Pac-12: Washington (Jack, Larry, Joe & Chris) vs Stanford (Josh, Sam, & Adam). Sounds about right. Although Oregon vs Stanford this Saturday night could tip the apple cart in Washington's favor (see what I did there???)
- SEC: Alabama vs Georgia. Ditto from the Nat'l Champ section
- Group of 5 NY6: South Florida (Jack) vs UCF (Larry/Josh) vs Boise State (the rest of us). Boise State is behind the 8-ball now and will be watching the showdown between the two Florida powerhouses on Nov 23 with great intrigue. ASIDE: Its possible that UCF and USF are better teams right now than the Holy Trinity of FSU, UF, and UM
Worst Team
- ACC: Virginia (Josh) vs UNC (all of us). What the hell happened in Chapel Hill? I assume they've cooled it on the whole "Orange Peeling 101 sounds like a perfectly legitimate course" thing and that's torpedo'd any chance of recruiting decent talent to a basketball school.
- Big Ten: Rutgers (Jack, Josh, Joe & Adam) vs Purdue (Larry) vs Illinois (Sam & Chris). A vintage race to the basement. Jeff Brohm likely steals a win or two in-conference, so Larry's out. But Lovie Smith annnnnnnd Greg Schiano??? Butch Jones???? Ralph Friedgen??? Curt Flood???? who the hell is coaching Rutgers?? Sounds like that answers my quandary. Rutgers likely wins the basement
- Big 12: I woulda sworn Kansas would get the clean sweep vote here, but Iowa State (Larry) and Texas (Josh) got some "love" here. Texas looked strong against USC on Saturday night and Iowa State gave Oklahoma a minor scare for a few quarters yesterday, but the real news is Kansas (the rest of us) beat the shit out of that coach-less Rutgers team. I'm beginning to doubt anyone gets points in this category.
- Pac-12: Oregon State (Jack, Joe, Sam, Adam & Chris) vs Arizona (Larry) vs UCLA (Josh). Perennial doormat Oregon State (man, those Chad Johnson/TJ Houshmanzadeh years are a looooooonnng time ago) might have some competition from Chip Kelly's talentless Bruins. Sorry, Larry, Khalil Tate can't suck all season. He'll figure things out and win a game or two. But the Beavers & Bruins could be sharing bunk beds in the cellar.
- SEC: Vanderbilt (Jack & Chris) vs Arkansas (Larry, Josh, Joe, & Sam) vs Missouri (Adam). This HAS to be Arkansas' to lose, right? They got absolutely crushed by North Texas on Saturday after getting beat by a meh Colorado State team the week before. No chance they turn around and beat anyone on their conference schedule.
Heisman Trophy
- Too many names to mention, but if Tua keeps it up Larry, Josh, Sam & Adam will be sitting pretty.
- I'm still liking my Kellen Mond one-off selection. He could steal the show from Tua on Saturday in Tuscaloosa just like another shifty, athletic A&M QB a few years back.
- Dwayne Haskins looks the part of a Heisman QB. That dude is luh-git.
Props: College
- Alabama Losses: Everyone (minus Chris) have Bama losing once. Seemed reasonable before Tua showed off his skills in more than just one half of football. Now? Its dicey. They will only get stronger and more unbeatable. This one is gonna be close.
- Count 'Em Up:
- Jack was savvy with his Kansas pick of 2 wins. They've achieved that and still have a one-game margin of error which they don't need. The rest of their schedule is unwinnable. Put this one in the books for Jack.
- Larry loves his Mississippi State Bulldogs and he's got them winning 10 this season. Traveling to Baton Rouge & Tuscaloosa will be big-time games for them, not to mention home tilts against Auburn & Texas A&M. Lose all four and Larry is playing for his 15 pts in the bowl game.
- Josh's affinity for the Gators is the exact opposite feeling I have for them. I'm Gator Bait, as they say in Gainesville. Florida's schedule is a week-to-week headscratcher. Does Dan Mullen's return to Starkville mean an emotional upset of the Bulldogs? Is Vanderbilt D's gonna overwhelm the inept Gator offense? Will FSU have figured things out by the end of the season? Will Idaho shock Gator Nation with a 35-10 drubbing in The Swamp? Josh might get 7 wins but they might not be the 7 wins he was expecting.
- Joe (11), Adam (12), & Chris (12) all picked Georgia and its safe to say that barring injuries (yes, it has to be plural, "injuries", because they can beat you in various ways) they should coast into 12 wins. Its all about the extra games. That's where they'll earn those secret paychecks.
- Sam kept the Super Fan 99 theme going with his selection of Tennessee and 6 wins which seems conservative & appropriate. Each game will certainly matter when landing at a .500 conclusion. Not much room for Jeremy Pruitt to get better throughout the season.
Jayhawks
- Incredibly Rock Chalk Jayhawk has managed to score our first points of the season. Larry, Joe, Sam, Adam, and Chris all locked up 15 pts when KU drug Rutgers behind the woodshed and beat them senseless. Kudos to us (not you, Jack & Josh, you suck)
CFB Win Increase
- We selected twenty-three (23) unique teams from every FBS conference (plus Independent BYU) except for the ACC. Not one team from the ACC seemed to be improved enough to catch anyone's eye. I'm considering tracking their progress separately to see if we screwed the pooch.
- The Big Ten (5) and the SEC (4) got the most love. I ain't so good at the math-uh-matics but something tells me they can't all improve. Read: sad-faced emoji in a few months for some of you
- The most common selection was Baylor with five participants: Jack, Josh, Joe, Sam, and Chris
- The difference-makers will be the single-selection teams:
- UConn - Larry
- Rutgers - Larry
- Tennessee - Larry
- East Carolina - Sam
- Kentucky - Sam
- West Virginia - Joe
- Michigan - Joe
- Maryland - Jack
- Arkansas - Jack
- Rice - Adam
- Charlotte - Adam
- Hawaii - Adam
- Colorado - Adam
- Ball State - Chris
- BYU - Chris
- Oregon State - Josh
- I managed to corner the market on difference-makers with four (4) teams all to myself. I'm truly in a ride-or-die situation. Thus far its working; I'm leading the crowd. Its gonna be tough to sustain, but I'm trying to be more optimistic these days.
I appreciate everyone taking the time to fill out the sheets. I'll update the Tracker tab on the Google Sheet every week on days when my kids cooperate and let me have an hour to myself. Enjoy the season and I'll see you soon for the NFL First Impressions.